An experience or a material product: Which new purchase is more likely to elicit envy in other consumers?

Imagine browsing through your social media feed and finding out about two purchases made by your friends. One friend went on a vacation to a tropical island. Another friend bought a new, top-of-the-line TV.

Which friend — the one who purchased an experience or the one who purchased a material product — are you more likely to envy?

The answer to this question wasn’t clear from the previous studies as some researchers argued one way while others argued the other way. A new paper by researchers at the University of Utah reconciles these findings and suggests that who we envy more depends on what we focus on as observers. The research will be published in the October issue of the Journal of Business Research and is online now at this link.

Joowon Park, lead author and an assistant professor of marketing at the University of Utah’s David Eccles School of Business, said: “When we focus on the people who made the purchase and think of how happy they are, we tend to envy experiential purchases more. When we focus on the products that were purchased and think of how great the products are, we tend to envy material purchases more.”

Why do people envy experiential purchases of others more when they focus on the people? Experiential purchases such as vacation trips, sporting events and concerts are more integral to one’s identity and have been shown to bring more happiness than material purchases. Thus, when observers focus on the people and their happiness, they envy experiential purchases more for the greater happiness they bring.

Why do people envy material purchases of others more when they focus on the product? Material purchases such as electronics and clothes are easier to compare on an objective basis than experiential purchases that are more subjective. Thus, when observers focus on the products and superiority of the products to their own, they envy material purchases more as they are easily comparable.

The researchers argue that naturally we, as social beings, tend to focus on the people aspect more often than product aspect.

“People will naturally engage in person-to-person comparisons online unless they are prompted otherwise to think more specifically about the purchase,” said Tamara Masters, a co-author and professor at the David Eccles School of Business.

These findings have implications for businesses that try to build on the power of envy, a strong motivator of consumption.

“Envy is more likely to generate interest if your company sells experiences than materials,” Park said. “See if you can highlight the experiential benefits your products bring to the consumers than merely listing the technical specs of your products in your marketing messaging.”

In addition to Park and Masters, the research team included Assistant Professor Sachin Banker, also from the University of Utah, and Grace Yu Buck, an assistant professor at the University of Houston Clear Lake.

###

About the David Eccles School of Business

The Eccles School is synonymous with “doing.” The Eccles experience provides a world-class business education with a unique, entrepreneurial focus on real-world scenarios where students put what they learn into practice long before graduation. Founded in 1917 and educating more than 6,000 students annually, the University of Utah David Eccles School of Business offers nine undergraduate majors, four MBAs, eight other graduate programs, a Ph.D. in five areas and executive education curricula. The school is also home to more than 20 institutes, centers and initiatives, which deliver academic research and support an ecosystem of entrepreneurship and innovation. For more information, visit Eccles.Utah.edu or call 801-581-7676.